Is immediate autologous breast reconstruction with postoperative radiotherapy good practice? A systematic review of the literature

Background There remains controversy as to whether immediate autologous breast reconstruction with postoperative radiotherapy is associated with acceptable complications and aesthetic outcomes. This systematic review analyses the literature regarding outcomes of immediate autologous breast reconstruction with postoperative radiotherapy compared with no radiotherapy, as well as with delayed autologous breast reconstruction following post-mastectomy irradiation. Methods Pubmed (1966 to October 2012), Ovid MEDLINE (1966 to October 2012), EMBASE (1980 to October 2012), and the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (Issue 10, 2012) were searched. Overall complications (including fat necrosis), fat necrosis, revisional surgery, loss of volume, and aesthetic outcome, were analysed individually. Comparable data from observational studies were combined for meta-analysis where possible and quality assessment of the studies was performed. Results The majority of studies of immediate autologous breast reconstruction and postoperative radiotherapy reported satisfactory outcomes (19 of 25 studies; n = 1247 patients). Meta-analysis of observational studies demonstrated no significant differences in total prevalence of complications (p = 0.59) or revisional surgery (p = 0.38) and a summary measure for fat necrosis favouring the group without radiotherapy (OR 2.82, 95% CI 1.35-5.92, p = 0.006). The majority of studies comparing immediate reconstruction and postoperative radiotherapy with delayed reconstruction following post-mastectomy radiotherapy (10 of 12 observational studies; n = 1633 patients) reported satisfactory outcomes following immediate reconstruction. Meta-analysis of observational studies demonstrated no significant difference in overall incidence of complications (p = 0.53) and fat necrosis (OR 0.63, 95% CI 0.29-1.38, p = 0.25), and a summary measure for revisional surgery (OR 0.15, 95% CI 0.05-0.48, p = 0.001) favouring the delayed surgery group. No randomised-controlled trials met the inclusion criteria, and all of the observational studies included were missing more than one important component for reporting of observational studies. Discussion The majority of studies reported satisfactory outcomes and a similar incidence of complications for immediate autologous breast reconstruction and adjuvant radiotherapy when compared with no radiotherapy or delayed reconstruction following radiotherapy; the proportion that required revisional surgery was higher though for immediate than delayed breast reconstruction. The findings are limited by the paucity of high quality data in the published literature, and until better data is available the findings of this review suggest that immediate autologous breast reconstruction should at least be considered when adjuvant chest wall radiotherapy is anticipated.