Molecular genetic differentiation between primary lung cancers and lung metastases of other tumors

When solitary pulmonary tumors are observed in patients with a history of cancer, differentiation between metastasis and primary lung cancer is crucial for appropriate therapy. Assuming that p53 mutations are conserved in metastases, mutation analysis of the p53 gene would be a valuable tool in differentiating metastases from primary carcinomas of the lung. In nine of 267 resected lung tumors, the origin of the lung tumor could not be defined histologically. Five patients had a history of colorectal carcinoma, one had a history of breast carcinoma, one had a history of soft-tissue carcinoma, and one had a history of head and neck carcinoma. One patient with a clear cell carcinoma of the lung had been surgically treated for both renal and thyroid cancer. Material from one patient with adenocarcinoma of the lung, histologically defined regional lymph nodes, and distant brain metastasis served as a control. We extracted deoxyribonucleic acid from the snap-frozen tissue of the unclassified lung tumors, from paraffin-embedded tissue of the previously removed primary cancers, and also from peripheral blood of the patients. Exons 2 to 11 of the p53 gene were amplified in separated polymerase chain reactions and directly sequenced. In all cases, the presence of germline mutations was excluded by analysis of peripheral blond deoxyribonucleic acid. The p53 mutation detected in the deoxyribonucleic acid of the lung tumor of the control patient proved to be conserved in the lymph nodes as well as in the brain metastasis. In two cases, the lung tumors exhibited a p53 mutation not present in the previously removed primary tumor and were therefore classified as new primary lung cancers. In five cases, the lung tumors proved to be metastases of the first tumor, exhibiting the identical p53 mutation. One of these lung tumor samples could be identified as a metastasis from the renal cancer, but the corresponding thyroid cancer material was different. For two cases, molecular analysis remained inconclusive. In one case, no p53 mutation could be found in the compared samples; in the other, no deoxyribonucleic acid could be extracted. Analysis of p53 mutations allowed exact classification in tumors for which standard methods failed to distinguish between metastasis or primary tumor. More than two thirds of lung tumors in patients with previous gastrointestinal carcinoma were revealed to be metastases, but second primary lung cancer could also be diagnosed. This diagnosis allowed correct surgical and adjuvant treatment of these patients.